Vivisection Is it for you Essay - 1749 Words

Vivisection: Is it for you? Animal Research has become a heated debate over the past few decades, reaching a high point around the end of the twentieth century yet it still continues through today. There are two main ways to look at this topic: the logos pro side and the pathos anti side. Those who are for animal testing realize the amazing benefits that can come out of such research while those against animal testing stand up for animals’ rights and try to find ways to better such research without killing so many innocent, defenseless animals. While both sides seem to carry their argument well, those against animal testing ruin their ethos by making their argument an emotional one while those who are for animal testing build†¦show more content†¦People against animal testing tend to not have the ability to convey themselves unemotionally when it comes to giving logical reasons for discontinuing its use. Many of the people who are against animal testing ask the same question: do animals not have just as much of a right to live as humans do? Their main argument, as seen in David Lewis’ article â€Å"Molecular Modeling as an Alternative to Animal Testing,† is that there are many alternative methods to animal testing. Lewis suggests in his article that we use computer simulations to get the information needed. If we have the ability to use alternative methods, why not use them? Computers have come a long way over the years and we should be able to save lives, human or animal, by using them. Such computer simulations can represent a large number of chemicals and compounds and how they would react to a living organism. Overall, those against animal testing use computer programs as a logical way to discontinue animal testing. One of Lewis’ arguments is that animal testing is not always reliable: â€Å"However, animal tests themselves have never been validated, and are often erroneously conducted and compiled† (Lewis). He feels that animal testing is unnecessary and sometimes even useless, so alternative methods must be used. The logos and ethos of the pro animal testing side of the debate are closely related. Since most of the articles that are proShow MoreRelatedThe Scientific Techniques Used For Experimentation Throughout The Ages1482 Words   |  6 Pagesthroughout the ages can spark controversy. In the The Island of Dr. Moreau, vivisection becomes the island’s culture. There are many aspects of vivisection that continuously overstep the rights of animals and the morals of humans. Dr. Moreau’s lack of sympathy for inflicting pain as well as the undeveloped jungle in which they experiment in also raises questions in how ethical this practice is. From a moral standpoint vivisection could be seen as wrong because of: the sanitary conditions of the islandRead MoreThe Island Of Doctor Moreau1708 Words   |  7 PagesThroughout time ethically controversial sciences, from vivisection to stem cell research, have embodied a negative stereotype in the eyes of western societies, and have conseq uently withdrawn the freedom that allows scientists to make innovative discoveries. In H.G. Wells novel The Island of Doctor Moreau, this perspective is portrayed through Edward Prendick, an upper class English gentleman with a subtle passion for science. After being stranded on a remote pacific island isolated from civilizationRead MoreVivisection Essay example1710 Words   |  7 Pagesa never ending argument of opinions. After doing research I found that there are more important reasons why this practice should be modified. Our government’s dependence on vivisection should be toned down or totally replaced because it is misleading, its faulty results, and with better alternatives available. Vivisection is defined as the cutting of live animals and applies to all experiments conducted on animals. Eighty-five percent of the animals used are rats and mice but dogs, cats, primatesRead MoreVivisection: Animal Experimentation1511 Words   |  7 PagesVivisection Many people today, including scientists and doctors, are questioning the suffering and killing of animals for the sake of human beings. Is it morally correct to dissect a frog or a worm for the purpose of educating a high school student? On the other hand, must We study life to protect life (1:131) The issue of killing animals for the use of biomedical research, education, and cosmetics can be referred as vivisection. Twenty-five to thirty-five million animals are spared in theRead MoreThe Island Of Doctor Moreau1687 Words   |  7 PagesBenjamin Rush once stated that â€Å"freedom can exist only in the society of knowledge. Without learning, men are incapable of knowing their rights† (Rush and Runes N.p). Throughout time, ethically controversial sciences, from vivisection to stem cell research, have embodied a negative stereotype in the eyes of western societies, and have consequently withdrew the freedom that allows scientists to make innovative discoveries. In H.G. Wells novel The Island of Doctor Moreau, this perspective is portrayedRead MoreAnimal Testing678 Words   |  3 Pagescontroversial topic in today’s society, much more than it was 100’s of years ago. Testing on animals was practiced long ago, and is still practiced today. Greek writings about vivisection [the dissection of a live organism] can be found dated as early as 500 BC. At that time, in Ancient Rome and Alexandria, and later in Greece, v ivisection was originally practiced on human criminals, but prohibitions on the mutilation of the human body soon arose. This caused a reliance on animals as a substitute for humansRead MoreIs the Killing of Animals for Research Okay? Essay1459 Words   |  6 Pages Vivisection nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Many people today, including scientists and doctors, are questioning the suffering and killing of animals for the sake of human beings. Is it morally correct to dissect a frog or a worm for the purpose of educating a high school student? On the other hand, must quot;We study life to protect lifequot; (1:131) The issue of killing animals for the use of biomedical research, education, and cosmetics can be referred as quot;vivisectionquot;. Twenty-fiveRead MoreAnimal Testing (Speech Outline)1200 Words   |  5 Pagesconflicts from pro-life activists, it will minimize lawsuits and morals will be preserved. br brbIntroduction/b brI. Okay I got a riddle I made up for the class. brA. What was once cute and furry but becomes a bloody rotted mess? brB. You guys give up? brC. Well the answer to this question is an animal that has undergone chemical testing. brII. I know that wasnt too funny but I needed some sort of attention-grabber and this hit home on the question of my topic; whether animal testingRead More Animal Experimentation is Necessary Essay1611 Words   |  7 Pagesjustify the termination of the dog labs at university.   The claim that the dog labs are cruel to the animals is unsubstantiated and inaccurate.   The claim that the labs are unnecessary is a falsity, as alternatives are not as beneficial as the vivisection labs.   Finally, the argument that th e labs are a waste of money is an ill-researched, erroneous depiction of the real circumstances.   Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   The dog labs are held annually at the University, on five consecutive Fridays in the early spring.   InRead MoreThe Mad Scientist Essay1649 Words   |  7 PagesMoreau, we experience the horrific environment of Moreau’s creations through Prendick. Initially, Prendick sees the immorality of Moreau’s work through the vivisection of human beings, but after talking with the doctor he realizes, â€Å"The creatures I had seen were not men, had never been men. They were animals – humanized animals – triumphs of vivisection† (Wells 222). This realization provides relief for Prendick as he sees he is not immediately threatened by Moreau’s work. However, as the reader we have